RareMetals.net

Holmium Recycling: What's Actually Recoverable

Holmium (Ho) recycling is not a "collect devices, melt metal" story. Holmium is usually a dopant or a small fraction inside high-spec materials (especially Ho:YAG laser crystals) or it appears in small quantities in certain rare-earth magnet streams. That means the only realistic holmium recycling is manufacturing scrap and targeted end-of-life streams where holmium is actually present and separable.

Best recycling economics

Manufacturing scrap from Ho:YAG laser crystal production

Main challenge

Separation capacity, not collection logistics

Demand context Supply chain structure Processing reality
Back to Holmium Overview

The core reality: holmium is concentrated in very few recyclable streams

Holmium is an important dopant in yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) lasers, along with other REE dopants (like erbium and neodymium). That is a real, persistent use case, and it creates a predictable scrap stream from laser crystal manufacturing.

At the same time, most consumer e-waste does not contain holmium in meaningful, recoverable concentrations. REE recycling from e-waste has historically been limited, with most activity centered on pre-consumer scrap (especially magnets) rather than post-consumer electronics.

Key insight: The best holmium recycling opportunities are in concentrated, known streams, not diffuse consumer electronics.

Stream 1: Ho:YAG and "RE:YAG" laser crystal manufacturing scrap

What the scrap looks like

Laser crystal production creates scrap in several forms:

  • Offcuts and rejected rods after machining/polishing
  • Leftover melt and crucible residues after crystal growth
  • Defective or out-of-spec crystals

These wastes are often referred to generally as RE:YAG single crystal waste (rare-earth-doped YAG), which includes Ho:YAG alongside Nd:YAG and other doped YAG variants. A patent on RE:YAG waste specifically describes separating and recovering rare earth components and aluminum from this waste stream.

Why this is the best holmium recycling path

  • Holmium is physically concentrated in a small mass of high-value material
  • Feed is consistent (same host crystal chemistry, known dopant profile)
  • It is usually "new scrap", meaning clean, collected, and traceable

How recovery is typically approached

Practical process logic

The exact plant flowsheet varies, but the playbook is consistent:

1

Mechanical size reduction

Crush/grind YAG scrap

2

Chemical decomposition

Decompose the YAG matrix so rare earths go into solution

3

Selective precipitation

Often oxalates or hydroxides to pull REEs out of solution

4

Separation/polishing

If the goal is individual oxides (holmium oxide vs yttrium oxide, etc.)

A technical publication on scrapped Nd:YAG crystal recycling explicitly describes a multi-step approach (including alkali melting and subsequent washing and leaching steps), which is directionally relevant because the host matrix problem is the same across RE:YAG scrap families.

The key limitation: even if you can recover "mixed REE," producing holmium oxide requires heavy-REE separation know-how and equipment. That is the same midstream bottleneck you see in primary supply.

Stream 2: Permanent magnet recycling where holmium is present

Most magnet recycling talk focuses on NdPr and sometimes Dy/Tb. Holmium is not a mainstream magnet rare earth, but it can show up in certain streams and can be recovered if it is present in the feed.

A 2025 study reports recovery and separation of neodymium and holmium from end-of-life permanent magnets from electric vehicle motors using a combined pyro- and hydrometallurgical approach.

What this means

  • Holmium-from-magnets is not the baseline case, but it is technically real
  • If the feed contains Ho, established magnet recycling toolkits (demagnetization, leaching, separation) can recover it
  • It still ends at the same step: separating individual rare earths to spec

For broader context on why magnet recycling has become the main "industrial" REE recycling pathway (and how it scales), the USITC review is a good reference point.

Stream 3: Post-consumer e-waste, optics, and "mixed junk" streams

This is where most recycling narratives fall apart for holmium

Post-consumer e-waste recycling for REEs has historically been limited and hard to scale, with activity skewed toward magnets and select polishing compounds rather than broad WEEE recovery.

Even when REE recovery from e-waste improves, it typically targets the highest concentration, easiest-to-collect parts first (magnets), not trace dopants in diverse products.

Reality check: If someone claims "holmium recycling from consumer electronics" as a near-term supply unlock, treat it as marketing until they show real feed concentration, real yields, and real separation output.

What "recycled holmium" looks like as a product

In practice, recycled holmium will usually appear as:

Early-stage recovery

Mixed rare earth concentrates or mixed oxalates/hydroxides

Final product (after separation)

Holmium oxide (Ho₂O₃) only after proper separation and polishing

That last step is hard, and it is why holmium recycling is ultimately a separation business more than a collection business.

Recycling FAQ

1) Can holmium be recycled from old smartphones or laptops?

Not realistically. Consumer electronics typically do not contain holmium in recoverable concentrations. While smartphones contain some rare earths (primarily in magnets and small amounts in other components), holmium is not among the economically recoverable elements from these devices. The collection, sorting, and separation costs far exceed the value of trace holmium.

2) Why is laser crystal scrap the best source for holmium recycling?

Laser crystal manufacturing scrap offers the ideal recycling conditions: high holmium concentration in a known, consistent matrix; clean, traceable material streams from manufacturing facilities; and established collection infrastructure at production sites. The scrap is also "pre-sorted" by its nature, eliminating the complex separation and sorting challenges that plague consumer e-waste recycling.

3) What prevents holmium recycling from scaling up?

The same constraint that limits primary holmium production: separation capacity. Even when recyclable material is collected, it must pass through complex solvent extraction circuits to isolate holmium from other rare earths. Building this separation infrastructure requires significant capital investment and technical expertise. Additionally, the total mass of holmium in circulation is small, limiting the absolute scale of recycling even under ideal conditions.

4) Is recycled holmium chemically different from mined holmium?

No. Once properly separated and refined, recycled holmium oxide (Ho₂O₃) is chemically identical to primary holmium oxide. The distinction between "recycled" and "primary" is only relevant for supply chain traceability and sustainability accounting. For technical applications like laser crystals or optical filters, what matters is purity and specification compliance, not origin.

5) Can holmium recycling reduce supply chain risk?

Only marginally. While manufacturing scrap recycling can improve material efficiency at production facilities, it does not fundamentally change geographic concentration of separation capacity. Recycling still requires access to the same rare earth separation infrastructure that processes primary material, which is concentrated in a few locations globally. Recycling is best viewed as a supplement to primary supply, not a replacement.