RareMetals.net

Cerium Substitutes: What Can Replace Ceria, and Where Substitution is Realistic

Most "cerium substitution" is really ceria (cerium oxide, CeO2) substitution, because ceria is the form used at scale in polishing, catalysts, and some glass applications.

Cerium is widely linked with glass polishing, glass additives, and automotive catalytic converters in mainstream rare earth end-use summaries.

Back to Cerium Overview | View Uses | View Supply Chain
1

Substitutes for Cerium Oxide in Glass Polishing and CMP

The main alternatives you'll actually see

In polishing and chemical-mechanical polishing (CMP), the most common non-ceria abrasive families discussed are:

Silica (SiO2)
Alumina (Al2O3)
Zirconia (ZrO2)
Titania (TiO2)
Diamond (often as a specialty or mixed abrasive)

Zirconia as a direct "replace ceria" candidate

A practical, industry-oriented route for reducing ceria usage in glass polishing is switching to zirconia abrasives. A conference paper focused specifically on developing alternative abrasives for glass polishing proposed ZrO2 as an alternative to CeO2 to reduce ceria use.

Silica and alumina: common, but performance trade-offs matter

Silica and alumina are widely used abrasives in CMP and polishing, but ceria often wins on the combination of removal rate and finish quality on silica-based surfaces.

For example, one comparative study on polishing performance reported higher removal rate and lower roughness for ceria slurry versus silica and alumina in its tested system.

A separate review of cerium recovery from polishing waste also notes that based on polishing-relevant criteria, ceria can outperform zirconia and alumina in glass polishing contexts.

The realistic outcome in polishing

In many real settings, "substitution" is not a clean swap. It tends to look like:

  • switching to another oxide abrasive for certain substrates or finish targets
  • changing pad chemistry, slurry chemistry, and process conditions to make non-ceria abrasives viable
  • using mixed abrasive systems (for example, ceria plus harder abrasives) when chasing throughput or defect reduction

If your goal is to reduce exposure to ceria supply or price swings, polishing is the application where substitution is most technically feasible, but also the one where performance penalties can show up fast.

2

Substitutes for Ceria in Automotive Catalysts and Oxygen-Storage Functions

Why ceria is hard to replace in catalytic converters

Ceria-based materials are widely used in three-way catalysts because they help buffer oxygen swings in exhaust conditions (the oxygen storage and release behavior).

So replacing ceria usually means replacing or redesigning the oxygen storage component, not just swapping a raw material.

Partial substitution: ceria-zirconia systems

One of the most common "reduce ceria pain" approaches is not eliminating ceria, but modifying it (for example, ceria-zirconia mixed oxides) to improve thermal stability and performance while optimizing ceria loading.

True alternative material classes: perovskites and spinels

Academic and technical literature discusses perovskite-type oxides as alternatives to conventional three-way catalyst compositions across multiple automotive catalyst applications.

There is also active work on other oxygen-storage-capable oxides. For example, a study comparing dynamic oxygen storage behavior examined ceria-zirconia versus an alumina-supported manganese-iron spinel system, reflecting ongoing interest in non-ceria oxygen storage concepts.

The realistic outcome in catalysts

Catalyst "substitution" is usually:

  • slower than polishing substitution (validation cycles are longer)
  • tied to emissions regulations and durability requirements
  • often ends up as partial replacement, doping, or architecture changes rather than a full ceria removal
3

Substitutes for Cerium in Glass Additives and Decolorizing

Cerium compounds can be used as glass additives that affect color and optical properties, but glassmakers have multiple pathways for controlling tint from iron impurities.

Manganese-based decoloration

Manganese chemistry has long been used to decolorize iron-containing glass via redox balancing, and modern research still discusses Mn-based decoloration mechanisms tied to Fe-Mn redox pairs.

Selenium as an industrial decolorizer

USGS mineral commodity summaries explicitly note selenium's use in glass manufacturing to decolorize the green tint caused by iron impurities in container glass and other soda-lime silica glass.

The realistic outcome in glass additives

In glass, "cerium substitution" often means:

  • • using alternative decolorizers (selenium, manganese systems) for tint control
  • • using different additive packages depending on UV/IR targets, color standards, and cost structure
4

Substitutes in Ceramics and Metallurgy

Cerium is cited across broad end-use buckets like ceramics and metallurgy. In these areas, substitution is usually less about finding a single "cerium replacement" and more about:

changing formulations (different stabilizers, fluxes, or dopants)
redesigning alloys or process controls to avoid a cerium-containing additive package

Because these uses are diverse, substitution tends to be application-specific rather than universal.

What Substitution Means for the Cerium Market

Cerium is often abundant relative to many rare earths, but it still depends on complex processing and separation capacity. If end users can switch away from ceria in polishing or reduce ceria loading in catalysts, it changes demand sensitivity.

If you're evaluating market risk and pricing drivers, this ties into:

→ Cerium investing → Mining and processing

Cerium Substitutes FAQ

What is the most practical substitute for cerium oxide in glass polishing?

Zirconia, silica, and alumina are the main abrasive families discussed as alternatives depending on the surface, finish target, and process chemistry. Zirconia has been proposed specifically as an alternative abrasive to reduce ceria use in glass polishing.

Can ceria be replaced in catalytic converters?

Sometimes partially, but it's hard. Ceria is widely used as an oxygen storage component in three-way catalysts. Alternatives discussed in the literature include different oxide classes such as perovskites, and other oxygen-storage-capable oxides are actively studied, but durability and validation are major hurdles.

Are manganese and selenium substitutes for cerium in glass decolorizing?

They can be, depending on what "job" cerium is doing in the glass. Manganese-based decoloration mechanisms are documented in glass research, and USGS notes selenium's role in decolorizing iron-driven green tint in common glass types.